By Cody Morris
What is the true measure of success in football? Is it the number of games won, championships claimed, or trophies brought home? Wins and losses get most of the attention, and maybe rightfully so. But is there more to the sport our local kids dedicate so much of their young lives to? Perhaps the hard work that goes into building culture, camaraderie and character simply can’t be measured by wins and losses alone.
By just about any metric you choose, our local area had two high school football programs put together nothing short of spectacular seasons. Both the Butler Bears and Appleton City Bulldogs saw their seasons come to an end this past Saturday, falling in the state playoffs. Both programs claimed district championships, experienced tremendous growth, and gave their communities plenty to be proud of. And that, in itself, is a win by any standard.
For Butler, there was a sense of uncertainty, but also excitement, this offseason as Coach Kyle Rhodes moved into town to take on his first head coaching job. The kids bought in.
The community began seeing Rhodes’ fingerprints on the program before a single game was played. Throughout the summer, he had his players participating in community service projects around town. Suddenly, it wasn’t just the kids buying in. The town of Butler was buying in, too. There was a growing belief that this new coach might really be building something special.
Then the season started. Was all that excitement justified? Would the hype translate to wins on Friday nights?
Butler opened the season 0-2, dropping its first two games. If there was ever a time for doubt to creep in, this was it.
But the Bears never wavered. They didn’t abandon the process, lose faith in their coach or give up on one another. Instead, they rattled off five consecutive victories, showing something that would come to define this Butler team: resilience.
Even when things got tough, the Bears kept fighting, eventually finishing the regular season with a 6-3 record.
But they weren’t finished. Rhodes had his team peaking at just the right time. The Bears opened district play with a dominant 68-18 victory over Lexington before following it up with a 70-8 dismantling of Lone Jack, earning their opportunity to compete for a district championship.
Entering the championship game against Lafayette County, Butler was viewed by many as the underdog. But that didn’t seem to bother the Bears. There was a quiet confidence surrounding the team, one that was quickly turning into loud excitement throughout the community. The Bears embraced the opportunity to prove themselves, and when the lights came on, they did exactly that.
Butler dominated Lafayette County, 52-8, bringing another district championship home to Bear country.
Of course, Rhodes’ culture change was only part of the equation. The Bears also boasted one of their most complete rosters in recent memory, with a list of standouts seemingly as long as a grocery receipt. Among them was senior Lucas Davidson, who helped lead Butler’s rushing attack with more than 2,000 yards and 30 rushing touchdowns through the district championship. But Davidson’s contributions extended well beyond the stat sheet, as his leadership and commitment to the program helped establish the very culture Rhodes had envisioned.
The Bears’ season ultimately came to an end this past Saturday against a talented Blair Oaks team. But while their final game ended in defeat, it’s difficult to look at what Butler accomplished this fall and call the season anything other than a victory.
While Butler’s championship represented the beginning of a new era, just down the road in Appleton City, the Bulldogs were celebrating something a little different. For Appleton City, this wasn’t the beginning of something new, but rather the result of something that had been building for years.
Under head coach Colton Bourland, the Bulldogs have been steadily building a football program that has become a force to be reckoned with. Each season, there seemed to be another step forward, another reason to believe that Appleton City was getting closer to something special.
And this year, the Bulldogs arrived.
Appleton City put together a spectacular season that saw the Bulldogs go undefeated in WEMO conference play, claiming a conference championship before adding a district title to their collection of hardware.
But this wasn’t a team that found success overnight. It was the result of years of hard work, dedication, and a group of kids who bought into what their coach was building. Bourland has preached the importance of doing the little things right, limiting mistakes, and playing four complete quarters of football. And this season, those little things added up to some pretty big accomplishments.
Of course, it helps when you have a roster loaded with talent. And loaded might be an understatement.
The Bulldogs were well represented on the WEMO All-Conference teams, with a long list of players earning recognition for their performances this season. Leading the way was quarterback Beau Brownsberger, who was named the WEMO Offensive Player of the Year, while teammate Weston Farmer earned Defensive Player of the Year honors.
Having the conference’s top offensive and defensive players on the same roster is impressive enough, but Appleton City’s talent didn’t stop there. Wyatt Davis, Griffin Strope, Chase Harkrader, Michael Smith and Elliott Leiber were among the many Bulldogs earning All-Conference recognition.
But individual accolades only tell part of the story. Football is a team sport, and what made this Appleton City team so special was the way all those pieces came together. From the playmakers putting points on the board to the guys doing the dirty work in the trenches, the Bulldogs found ways to get the job done.
And for a community that has watched this program continue to grow, there had to be something pretty special about seeing all that hard work rewarded with a district championship.
Like Butler, Appleton City’s season eventually came to an end in the state playoffs. And while there was undoubtedly disappointment in that locker room, there should also be an overwhelming sense of pride.
Because the Bulldogs didn’t just have a good season. They showed what can happen when a program continues to build, when players believe in one another, and when years of hard work finally come together.
Appleton City has been knocking on the door for a while now. This year, the Bulldogs kicked it open.
Two different programs. Two different journeys. Two district championships.
For the seniors on both teams, they leave behind something that extends far beyond a championship trophy. They leave behind examples for the younger players to follow, memories their communities will cherish, and football programs that are better because of their contributions. Maybe that’s the true measure of winning after all.
#MidAmericaLive